I Swear....
Unbelievable.
No, wait, I only wish it was unbelievable.
Keith Ellison is my newly elected Congressman. He's a Democrat. He also happens to be a Muslim.
That's not the unbelievable part. I couldn't really care less that he's Muslim. His religious beliefs are his own. I care about him voting the right way on things that actually affect the future of this country. Because I think he'll do that, I voted for him.
Apparently, however, many people do in fact care that he's a Muslim. Or at least that he refuses to hide the fact that he's Muslim and won't pretend to be a Christian when he swears his oath of office.
This all blew up the first time a month or so ago when Ellison let it be known that he would place his hand on the Koran when he took his oath, rather than on the Bible. I hardly took notice of the announcement because a) I don't care what book he puts his hand on as long as he upholds the Constitution; and b) Duh! He's Muslim. Why in any deity's name would he swear his oath on the Christian Bible?
Well, a right-wing blow-hard dumbass named Dennis Prager didn't see it that way. He wrote a piece published on right-wing websites decrying Ellison's decision as an act that "undermines American civilization."
Yes, he was serious. No, it was not published in the Onion.
Everyone must swear on the Bible, Prager wrote, because "America is interested in only one book, the Bible. If you are incapable of taking an oath on that book, don't serve in Congress .... Mr. Ellison, America, not you, decides on what book its public servants take their oath."
Reading Prager's article inspired in me a strong desire to ask him three questions:
1. Have you ever actually read the Constitution? I know it's hard to read all those words, but did you at least make it to the First Amendment? The one about Congress not establishing a religion?
2. Do you have no sense of irony (much less decency)?
3. Would you kindly shut the hell up?
I didn't ask those questions at the time, or write anything else about Prager's idiotic article, because even though this is America, and Prager has a right to be wrong, I prefer not to add, even in a small way, to the dissemination of wrongness on this scale. My naive hope was that it would simply fade away into unread oblivion.
Much like this blog.
No such luck. Prager not only got air time from Sean Hannity, but he also got to appear on real news channels like CNN with real journalists. Still, I held my peace, hoping it would blow over.
Wrong again. This time the outrage came from the Commonwealth of Virginia, where citizens apparently actually took time to write their own congressman -- Republican Virgil Goode -- to share their dismay that a guy they didn't elect from a state they don't live in was swearing an oath on the Koran out of respect for a religion they don't practice. In a letter to those constituents (and you have no idea the self-restaint it's taking to keep me from making some entirely unfair, gross generalization about the intelligence and/or education of said Virginians) Goode made it known that he shared their pain. But he also has the solution:
First, "the Muslim Representative's" name is Keith. Where do you think he came from? (For the record, he was born in Detroit. Which, Representative Goode, is a city in Michigan. Which, I should also make sure you understand, is a state. In the United States. Of America).
Second, I'm pretty sure (though I haven't bothered to look it up) the largest block of immigrants coming to this nation is from Latin America. Latinos tend to be Christian, not Muslim. I know you think they all have brown skin Representative Goode, but even if that were true (it isn't) it would not mean they are all the same.
Third, READ THE FUCKING CONSTITUTION! Discriminating against people for their religious beliefs violates it, and your attempt to do so violates your oath of office.
No, wait, I only wish it was unbelievable.
Keith Ellison is my newly elected Congressman. He's a Democrat. He also happens to be a Muslim.
That's not the unbelievable part. I couldn't really care less that he's Muslim. His religious beliefs are his own. I care about him voting the right way on things that actually affect the future of this country. Because I think he'll do that, I voted for him.
Apparently, however, many people do in fact care that he's a Muslim. Or at least that he refuses to hide the fact that he's Muslim and won't pretend to be a Christian when he swears his oath of office.
This all blew up the first time a month or so ago when Ellison let it be known that he would place his hand on the Koran when he took his oath, rather than on the Bible. I hardly took notice of the announcement because a) I don't care what book he puts his hand on as long as he upholds the Constitution; and b) Duh! He's Muslim. Why in any deity's name would he swear his oath on the Christian Bible?
Well, a right-wing blow-hard dumbass named Dennis Prager didn't see it that way. He wrote a piece published on right-wing websites decrying Ellison's decision as an act that "undermines American civilization."
Yes, he was serious. No, it was not published in the Onion.
Everyone must swear on the Bible, Prager wrote, because "America is interested in only one book, the Bible. If you are incapable of taking an oath on that book, don't serve in Congress .... Mr. Ellison, America, not you, decides on what book its public servants take their oath."
Reading Prager's article inspired in me a strong desire to ask him three questions:
1. Have you ever actually read the Constitution? I know it's hard to read all those words, but did you at least make it to the First Amendment? The one about Congress not establishing a religion?
2. Do you have no sense of irony (much less decency)?
3. Would you kindly shut the hell up?
I didn't ask those questions at the time, or write anything else about Prager's idiotic article, because even though this is America, and Prager has a right to be wrong, I prefer not to add, even in a small way, to the dissemination of wrongness on this scale. My naive hope was that it would simply fade away into unread oblivion.
Much like this blog.
No such luck. Prager not only got air time from Sean Hannity, but he also got to appear on real news channels like CNN with real journalists. Still, I held my peace, hoping it would blow over.
Wrong again. This time the outrage came from the Commonwealth of Virginia, where citizens apparently actually took time to write their own congressman -- Republican Virgil Goode -- to share their dismay that a guy they didn't elect from a state they don't live in was swearing an oath on the Koran out of respect for a religion they don't practice. In a letter to those constituents (and you have no idea the self-restaint it's taking to keep me from making some entirely unfair, gross generalization about the intelligence and/or education of said Virginians) Goode made it known that he shared their pain. But he also has the solution:
The Muslim Representative from Minnesota was elected by the voters of that district and if American citizens don't wake up and adopt the Virgil Goode position on immigration, there will likely be many more Muslims elected to office and demanding the use of the Koran. I fear that in the next century we will have many more Muslims in the United States if we do not adopt the strict immigration policies that I believe are necessary to preserve the values and beliefs traditional to the United States of America.Ok, this thing has gotten long enough, and I have videogames to play, so just a few quick points in response to the distinguished jackass from Virginia.
First, "the Muslim Representative's" name is Keith. Where do you think he came from? (For the record, he was born in Detroit. Which, Representative Goode, is a city in Michigan. Which, I should also make sure you understand, is a state. In the United States. Of America).
Second, I'm pretty sure (though I haven't bothered to look it up) the largest block of immigrants coming to this nation is from Latin America. Latinos tend to be Christian, not Muslim. I know you think they all have brown skin Representative Goode, but even if that were true (it isn't) it would not mean they are all the same.
Third, READ THE FUCKING CONSTITUTION! Discriminating against people for their religious beliefs violates it, and your attempt to do so violates your oath of office.

3 Comments:
At 8:55 AM,
John Merland said…
I think we need a stronger immigration policy regarding Detroit. We don't need those Detroit people roaming around this country all wily nilly taking our jobs and replacing our god.
At 10:17 PM,
Anonymous said…
As sad as this is, your blog made me laugh...and God knows I needed to do that. Thanks!
At 7:47 AM,
Anonymous said…
Oh boy! If ignorance is bliss, then we've got one happy Congressman in Virgil Goode. Let's see Virginia has given the U.S. distinguished "Founding Fathers" such as Washington, Jefferson, Madison. Such institutions as William & Mary, UVA, the Virginia Musem of Fine Arts etc.
Now we get a nitwit elected by like minds. Hey, Southside Virginia, immigration and religious diversity aren't causing your problems. You are! Goode's just the latest example of a regional myopia that either refuses or is incapable of rational thought. NASCAR may love them, but Osama loves them even more as he's playing right into Al-Queda's hands. Where are your Klan robes, Bubba?
Post a Comment
<< Home